osprey_archer (
osprey_archer) wrote2025-07-17 10:21 am
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Entry tags:
Book Review: Queer Person
The Newbery project continues with Ralph Hubbard’s Queer Person, which begins with a child of about four wandering into a Pikuni camp in the middle of a blizzard. He wanders from tepee to tepee, taken in and then turned away as the inhabitants decide he’s an idiot, until at last he reaches the last tepee in the village, where the irascible old woman recognizes that he’s deaf and dumb and takes him in.
He grows up an outcast, called Queer Person and considered a fool by most of the people in the village, although Granny and a few friends learn to talk to him with their hands (using, I think, an expanded version of the Plains sign language) and recognize his talent for building things. In his teens, a bout of heatstroke causes a couple of hard worm-shaped objects to fall out of his ears, enabling him once again to hear. Granny explains that sometimes fevers plug the ears like this. She suggests that he should hide his new abilities until he’s mastered spoken language.
Meanwhile! We veer into Problem of Tomboys territory! The boys of the camp are riding a yearling buffalo, which came into camp as a pet but has now grown too big for comfort. One of the boys dares the girls that none of them will dare to ride it, at which point the chief’s daughter Singing Moon rides the buffalo across the plains, jumping off just in time before it rejoins the buffalo herd.
Impressed by her bravery, Granny and an older warrior suggest that Singing Moon join the next warrior raid - in disguise, of course, at least at first. After all, Granny did it herself in her youth, and her presence rallied the warriors to great feats of bravery! And so does Singing Moon’s, but the greatest feat of all is her own success in counting coup on an enemy, knocking him off his horse and taking the horse for a trophy.
Singing Moon is of course the love interest, and the next bit of the book involves Queer Person proving that he can match her in bravery - not through the traditional route of going into battle, but by saving Singing Moon’s kidnapped little brother. Queer Person sneaks into the camp of a rival tribe, where he’s captured, but they’re so impressed by his bravery in coming into their camp unarmed that they decide to subject him to tests rather than kill him outright, ending in a test where he has to battle an old warrior who has decided that he’d like to go out gloriously in single combat with this brave outsider.
The old warrior is, of course! Queer Person’s father.
Then Queer Person heads home, returns the kidnapped child to his family, reveals he can talk, sleeps for three days, and then marries Singing Moon.
Ralph Hubbard (also known as “Doc” Hubbard) was a professor who promoted Native American culture, and he clearly put a ton of research into the background of this story. (He also later had an asteroid named after him. And he was the son of Elbert Hubbard, who wrote “A Message to Garcia,” founded an Arts and Crafts community called the Roycroft Shops, and died in the sinking of the Lusitania.)
He grows up an outcast, called Queer Person and considered a fool by most of the people in the village, although Granny and a few friends learn to talk to him with their hands (using, I think, an expanded version of the Plains sign language) and recognize his talent for building things. In his teens, a bout of heatstroke causes a couple of hard worm-shaped objects to fall out of his ears, enabling him once again to hear. Granny explains that sometimes fevers plug the ears like this. She suggests that he should hide his new abilities until he’s mastered spoken language.
Meanwhile! We veer into Problem of Tomboys territory! The boys of the camp are riding a yearling buffalo, which came into camp as a pet but has now grown too big for comfort. One of the boys dares the girls that none of them will dare to ride it, at which point the chief’s daughter Singing Moon rides the buffalo across the plains, jumping off just in time before it rejoins the buffalo herd.
Impressed by her bravery, Granny and an older warrior suggest that Singing Moon join the next warrior raid - in disguise, of course, at least at first. After all, Granny did it herself in her youth, and her presence rallied the warriors to great feats of bravery! And so does Singing Moon’s, but the greatest feat of all is her own success in counting coup on an enemy, knocking him off his horse and taking the horse for a trophy.
Singing Moon is of course the love interest, and the next bit of the book involves Queer Person proving that he can match her in bravery - not through the traditional route of going into battle, but by saving Singing Moon’s kidnapped little brother. Queer Person sneaks into the camp of a rival tribe, where he’s captured, but they’re so impressed by his bravery in coming into their camp unarmed that they decide to subject him to tests rather than kill him outright, ending in a test where he has to battle an old warrior who has decided that he’d like to go out gloriously in single combat with this brave outsider.
The old warrior is, of course! Queer Person’s father.
Then Queer Person heads home, returns the kidnapped child to his family, reveals he can talk, sleeps for three days, and then marries Singing Moon.
Ralph Hubbard (also known as “Doc” Hubbard) was a professor who promoted Native American culture, and he clearly put a ton of research into the background of this story. (He also later had an asteroid named after him. And he was the son of Elbert Hubbard, who wrote “A Message to Garcia,” founded an Arts and Crafts community called the Roycroft Shops, and died in the sinking of the Lusitania.)